Well, I just got my masters feedback,
I do not mind critiques,... even when it is 25 pages worth.... but the tone of some of these academics is unprofessional, rude and demotivational.
I had 3 exainers:
Examiner no. 1 was very very thorough and accounted for 10 pages of suggested corrections - all good ideas! All comments were objective.
Examiner no. 2 clearly did not read the thesis properly, most of his suggestions were already in place. But the tone of his comments was sarcastic and in a lit of cases belittling. However, some of the ideas this one had were quite good and reinforced examiner no. 1's comments.
Examiner no. 3 made comments like 'Was this written by a high school student or a university student?' <-- very unhelpful, sarcastic and unprofessional comment to make. This one really did not like the new ideas i was giving.
These faceless examiners hide behind their degrees and such, I reckon none of them have formal teacher training - if they they would know to never put a person down if you are trying to help them.
I think examiner 3 feels threatened...
I do not mind critiques,... even when it is 25 pages worth.... but the tone of some of these academics is unprofessional, rude and demotivational.
I had 3 exainers:
Examiner no. 1 was very very thorough and accounted for 10 pages of suggested corrections - all good ideas! All comments were objective.
Examiner no. 2 clearly did not read the thesis properly, most of his suggestions were already in place. But the tone of his comments was sarcastic and in a lit of cases belittling. However, some of the ideas this one had were quite good and reinforced examiner no. 1's comments.
Examiner no. 3 made comments like 'Was this written by a high school student or a university student?' <-- very unhelpful, sarcastic and unprofessional comment to make. This one really did not like the new ideas i was giving.
These faceless examiners hide behind their degrees and such, I reckon none of them have formal teacher training - if they they would know to never put a person down if you are trying to help them.
I think examiner 3 feels threatened...
Comment