Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Stickin' to it!

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • TimmyHate
    replied
    Autos are getting more common over here - personally I would love to have a manual but my (American) wife cannot drive manual - she tried learning in my little Integra (god I loved that car) which had one of the most forgiving clutches in history. Sadly she couldn't get the hang of it and then, when she would stall, she'd start to panic. She's had a few bad experiences in cars before so that might play into it (she still refuses to go on the motorway).

    Right now we've got an 06 Subaru Legacy - 4 speed auto but with a manual/tiptronic option. Not quite the control I love from a Manual but better than nothing.

    Leave a comment:


  • Sapphire Silk
    replied
    Quoth Golden Phoenix View Post
    I recall a tv show from many years ago (Possibly called driving school?) featuring a woman named Maureen Rees who had failed her test many times, possibly as many as twenty times according to unsubstantiated googled forum posts, and much ado was made about the fact that she eventually passed, by learning in an automatic.
    My father taught me on an automatic, even though we also had a stick, and would not teach me stick until I had proven myself a good driver on automatic. He felt that it was best to take advantage of learning good driving habits (rules of the road) without the distraction of shifting, and THEN add in the complication of shifting gears. I think he was right. I did have some trouble learning stick, but that was because I learned on my brothers car, which was a piece of crap with the tightest clutch I've ever used in my life . . . so naturally I had a hard time not stalling. When I later switched to driving Dad's car (also a stick) it was a breeze and I've never had trouble since. I've owned a couple of stick shifts: my old Honda Civic Wagon, and my Jeep CJ 7.

    Quoth wolfie View Post
    I was under the impression that "standard" and "stick" both referred to a manual transmission. What's the distinction between them.
    I don't think there is a difference; I think the terms both mean the same thing.

    Quoth wolfie View Post
    I hope the vehicle in question was one where the parking brake was a hand lever (both manual and automatic versions of my car have this type), instead of a foot pedal conveniently located to the left of the brake (as in most minivans). The second type could get rather interesting for someone who's used to driving a manual.
    My Jeep had a foot brake instead of a hand brake. Never had any problems.

    Quoth Akasa View Post
    The only stick I've driven is 3-on-tree.
    I'm afraid my dyslexia would make me a dangerous driver of traditional stick shift vehicles.
    It might be easier than you think. Once you learn what positions to pull the shift in, it becomes second nature. You don't even think about it.

    Quoth NecessaryCatharsis View Post
    I once tried to explain to a garage owner that I was disturbed when I went to pick my car up that the parking brake wasn't on and the bumper was touching a tree. He said that was policy, that they had once had to pay for a brake that had seized when the vehicle owner blamed the mechanic who parked it for breaking it because 'nobody uses the emergency brake except for an emergency'.
    My dad taught me to always use the parking brake, even when I first learned to drive on an automatic. Maybe it's because that's how he learned, but it's an ingrained habit. EE's husband gives me a hard time about it because he doesn't think it's necessary, but I prefer knowing my car's not going anywhere even if I'm driving an automatic. I most definitely never fail to engage the parking brake on a stick shift.

    Leave a comment:


  • otakuneko
    replied
    Quoth MadMike View Post
    Not only did I keep reaching for a shifter that wasn't there,
    My Impreza's shifter could easily be mistaken for that of a stick shift. It's in the right place, such that it'd be natural for you to reach for it, it's got a familiar shape (as opposed to previous automatics I've driven, where the shape was a dead giveaway), the only tell is the trigger on the front. Manuals don't have a button to release the stick.

    Try to "shift" with it though and while you can throw it left or right, you'll only be toggling manual mode on and off. "Manual mode" doesn't enable/disable the flappy paddles--they're always on--it just tells the tranny not to take back over after a certain time.

    Leave a comment:


  • mathnerd
    replied
    I've been driving this van for a few months now, and still, when I get into a situation where I'm operating on instinct (accident avoidance type stuff), I still find my left foot trying to jam in the clutch and my right hand looking for the gear shift. Thankfully this van has an hand lever e-brake and a gear shift on the tree, so I haven't managed to screw up too badly.

    Leave a comment:


  • NecessaryCatharsis
    replied
    Quoth MadMike View Post
    In addition to putting the parking brake on, my dad also taught me to leave it in gear when it's parked, so that if the brake somehow failed, then it was still less likely to roll away. I got into an argument with my ex over that.....
    I once tried to explain to a garage owner that I was disturbed when I went to pick my car up that the parking brake wasn't on and the bumper was touching a tree. He said that was policy, that they had once had to pay for a brake that had seized when the vehicle owner blamed the mechanic who parked it for breaking it because 'nobody uses the emergency brake except for an emergency'. So his mechanics were trained not put on the parking brake when they put cars in the yard, even on a standard. That`s also when I found out that mine was the first standard they had in for almost 3 years, and that there was only person on staff who would drive it. He was off when my car was done, and the rest of the guys pushed it out to the parking lot. I did inform my insurance company of the garages behaviour. Coincidently that garage wasn`t on the list of preferred shops I was given a few weeks ago to get my car`s damage assessed. I wonder why

    Quoth MadMike View Post
    Not only did I keep reaching for a shifter that wasn't there, one time I pushed my left foot down on the brake, thinking it was the clutch.
    I`ve done that a few times, but only in the worst situations. I`ve decided I am not a good automatic driver!

    Leave a comment:


  • MadMike
    replied
    I drive an automatic now, but I learned on stick. My dad was the one who taught me, and that's all he had to teach me with. It was frustrating at first, but now I'm glad I know how to do it. You never know when you're going to need it, like when I rented a U-Haul, and the only thing they had was this piece of junk that must have been at least 20 years old, and was a stick shift.

    In addition to putting the parking brake on, my dad also taught me to leave it in gear when it's parked, so that if the brake somehow failed, then it was still less likely to roll away. I got into an argument with my ex over that. It seems that when she went to borrow my car one time, she didn't bother to take it out of gear before she started it up, and it lurched forward. She came back inside and started screaming at me for it. I tried to explain that I left it in gear for a reason, and told her that a) she should have checked it before she started it up, and b) she was lucky I was even letting her use my car, but of course, she was always right and I was always wrong.

    I drove stick for over a decade before I finally got an automatic. Before that, I had driven a few rental cars, which were automatic, and it took some getting used to. Not only did I keep reaching for a shifter that wasn't there, one time I pushed my left foot down on the brake, thinking it was the clutch. I got yelled at for that one too.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jetfire
    replied
    Quoth Pagan View Post
    I was thinking the same thing.

    Bad wording on my part that I didn't notice. I meant Automatic.

    Leave a comment:


  • RealUnimportant
    replied
    I've driven both manual and auto in LHD and RHD cars on both sides of the pond, and after a couple of years with a couple of large high powered autos I'm much happier to be back in a small (well, a bit smaller) manual car. Autos are heavier, generally slower to get going, and more expensive to fix when they go wrong - unless you have a very modern manual with a dual mass flywheel! That said, my smallest car (I have a few) is an auto, and is a blast because it's easiest to drive it with one foot on each pedal! Makes for some fun time navigating the tiny gaps in city traffic when you can just brake, turn and accelerate without moving your feet or worrying about which gear you're in

    Over here if you pass your test in an auto, you can't drive stick without retaking the entire test... This is mostly only done by those with physical difficulty using full standard controls.

    Leave a comment:


  • Akasa
    replied
    The only stick I've driven is 3-on-tree.
    I'm afraid my dyslexia would make me a dangerous driver of traditional stick shift vehicles.

    Leave a comment:


  • DGoddessChardonnay
    replied
    Quoth MoonCat View Post
    I have 10 or 12 places in mind that I'd like to drive one of those through right now...
    Downtown wouldn't be a good choice . . . .might run into a building or some such.

    Now I'm reminded of two brothers who took a joy ride in one of those they found hiding in their parents' garage.

    Better that than go next door to their crazy aunt who had a missile silo installed her her backyard past the pool.

    Leave a comment:


  • Pagan
    replied
    Quoth Jetfire View Post
    Ah learning to drive a stick. If I were forced to I could probably do it, but otherwise I'll stick with a standard.
    Quoth wolfie View Post
    I was under the impression that "standard" and "stick" both referred to a manual transmission. What's the distinction between them.
    I was thinking the same thing.

    Leave a comment:


  • greek_jester
    replied
    Quoth Android Kaeli View Post
    Wait, there are still cars with stick shifts? *mind blown*
    Don't ever come to the UK then; automatics are nearly as rare as hen's teeth. They're rarely used by anyone other than people with mobility issues, and they sell at a much lower price because they're so unpopular.

    Leave a comment:


  • AccountingDrone
    replied
    Quoth Android Kaeli View Post
    Wait, there are still cars with stick shifts? *mind blown*

    In all seriousness, when I was looking for a new car some odd years ago the roommate pointed out that the stick shift cars were about 3-5k less then the automatic and said that I should consider getting one. I told her as I'm about to tell everyone else: I've never driven a stick, I've never learned how to drive one, and if you don't want to pick my body from the morgue, I'm sticking with an automatic.
    Yup =) Currently sitting out front is a 1984 Chevy S-10 [Zombie 2] that is a manual, a 1996 VW Jetta in manual, a Grand Caravan momvan in auto and a 2006 VW Jetta in diesel automatic. We have never locked the s10 or the 96 jetta, leave the keys n the visor of the s10 and am proud to say that neither the unlocked jetta nor the keys in s10 have ever been taken for a joy ride [despite a spate of stolen cars in our county and area about 2 years back ]

    My ultimate desired vehicle right now would be the diesel manual Ford Kuga we rented in Germany about 5 years back ... the ergonomics were fantastic, it was amazingly comfortable and was a blast on the autobahn in the open speed sections, there is something viscerally satisfying about opening up and seeming to float past cars gently strolling along in the right lane and not worrying about cops [backstory - I learned to drive in 2 vehicles, a 1973 Chrysler New Yorker, the largest wheelbased car other than a limo in the US at the time] and a Ferrari 308 GTB, a the time I was dating a race driver. I am *really* accomplished at driving urban tanks and sports cars, and I have owned several fairly high end sports cars over the years. I adore manuals =) ]

    Leave a comment:


  • Golden Phoenix
    replied
    I'll admit I haven't driven much since I passed my test 9 years ago, but I don't recall ever even riding in an automatic.

    I know they exist in the UK, but i've never seen one. My driving instructor had a manual, and it seems to be pretty much assumed that manual is the default over here.

    Or maybe I'm just a bit oblivious...

    I recall a tv show from many years ago (Possibly called driving school?) featuring a woman named Maureen Rees who had failed her test many times, possibly as many as twenty times according to unsubstantiated googled forum posts, and much ado was made about the fact that she eventually passed, by learning in an automatic.

    (Quick note: Internet rumour has it that she later passed both her manual test, and an advanced drivers test and is now herself a driving instructor!)

    EDIT: Further checking says she passed on her 7th attempt and instead used her reality tv money to set up her own cleaning company.

    Leave a comment:


  • wolfie
    replied
    Quoth Argabarga View Post
    You remembered to put the e-brake on when you parked, a surprising number of people don't do that with manual transmissions. At least a few of which we have to tow every year when they come out of the classroom/gym/McDonalds and find that they neglected to do the same and as a result, their car got taken on a joyride by gravity, and there's now upwards of 3 other car owners and at least one friendly police officer who'd like to have a word with them about that....
    My employer used to have a couple "short term" parking spots that were VERY convenient for people who just needed to get their paperwork. Those spots are now "No Parking". Why? People were forgetting to set their parking brakes, and there was a slight slope. A couple vehicles headed out the driveway (straight shot from these spaces), across a major street, and through the fence on the other side - fortunately, no cars on the street got hit. Why weren't they left in gear? The company trucks have a "safety feature" where the starter only works in neutral, so people typically shift into neutral before parking (why can't the switch be on the clutch pedal the way my car has it?). Anyone notice how I said "company TRUCKS"? Yep, these runaways were 18 wheelers.

    Quoth Jetfire View Post
    Ah learning to drive a stick. If I were forced to I could probably do it, but otherwise I'll stick with a standard.
    I was under the impression that "standard" and "stick" both referred to a manual transmission. What's the distinction between them.

    Quoth mathnerd View Post
    I had quite the opposite experience recently: learning how to drive an automatic. I'm 38 years old and in April I purchased my very first automatic. There were some interesting times getting used to it.
    I hope the vehicle in question was one where the parking brake was a hand lever (both manual and automatic versions of my car have this type), instead of a foot pedal conveniently located to the left of the brake (as in most minivans). The second type could get rather interesting for someone who's used to driving a manual.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X