Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The greatest guitar player of al time?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The greatest guitar player of al time?

    If I wasn't in the middle of a 2+ hour drive or it was one of the "best of" days (where they replay the best bits - usually when one person it out) I would have called a local morning show with a strong disagreement with what they said.

    They were talking about the albums that ruined classic rock and they got on the topic of one guitar player (I forgot who they were talking about). The younger members commented on someone and the lead person (older) shot back that this person is no Jimmy Page and then go on to say that Jimmy Page is the greatest guitarist of all times. I had to strongly disagree.

    I don't want to hear people trashing me thinking that I think he sucks, he has no talent, etc. Jimmy Page is a PHENOMINAL guitar player. I'll even agree he's up there - one of the best and Led Zeppelin is one of my favorite bands (so I don't want to hear people saying I think they are bad).

    I just don't think he is the best guitar player. Here are some others I think are as good, or even better, than he is.

    Nuno Bettencourt (Extreme). This guy is up there. While Extreme never achieved the fame and success Led Zeppelin did Nuno is, IMO, one of the best guitar players I've ever heard (on par with Page - maybe slightly above). When you hear the solo from "Do You Wanna Play" played live it's just incredible how he does that.

    Barry Goudreau (Boston). While his skills with the guitar are not as high as Page his inventiveness with the instrument, even teaming up with other band members to invent new pedals / effects for the guitar. He had a lot of creativity and was able to make the guitar more than it was before.

    Terry Kath (Chicago). His life was cut short and people remember him more for his addictive baritone voice, he was also a great guitar player. Terry played the guitar like any of us breathe and he is also credited for being one of the (if not the) first people to "shred" (a.k.a. shredder) their guitar. (Yes, the Scoripions are technically credited with this but Terry was doing it 4 years before they did).

    Eric Clapton (Derek and the Dominoes, Cream, solo) - do I need to continue?

    Who do I think is the best?

    Brian May (from Queen and other projects). He had it all, inventiveness, the dexterity to control the instrument, the stamina to remain as a very strong guitar player for over 30 years, and, the best part - he made his own guitar (with his father). The "Red Special" (as it was called by other band members) is a one of a kind with a unique sound, rumor also has it that Brian usually didn't use a guitar pick - he used a coin ( I can't find any official confirmation on this - just rumors).

    Brian could play a C-major scale on his guitar and make it sound like a hit.
    Quote Dalesys:
    ... as in "Ifn thet dawg comes at me, Ima gonna shutz ma panz!"

  • #2
    Oh jeeze, you have to ask?!

    Jimmy Hendrix all the way.
    Ridiculous 2009 Predictions: Evil Queen will beat Martha Stewart to death with a muffin pan. All hail Evil Queen! (Some things don't need elaboration.....) -- Jester

    Ridiculous 2010 Predictions: Evil Queen, after escaping prison for last years prediction, goes out and waffle irons Rachel Ray to death. -- SG15Z

    Ridiculous 2011 Prediction: Evil Queen will beat Gordon Ramsay over the head with a cast-iron skillet. -- FireHeart

    Comment


    • #3
      As I've often said, if they ever made Black Flag Guitar Hero, nobody would ever win it. Greg Ginn just goes up and down the fretboard and all over the place. It doesn't sound particularly musical, but it still takes talent.

      Don't think I'd call him the greatest ever, but he's in my top 10 at least.
      Knowledge is power. Power corrupts. Study hard. Be evil.

      "I never said I wasn't a horrible person."--Me, almost daily

      Comment


      • #4
        Jimi Hendrix, definitely. I'd also add Carlos Santana to the list.
        I don't have an attitude problem. You have a perception problem.
        My LiveJournal
        A page we can all agree with!

        Comment


        • #5
          That I've seen?
          Jimi Hendrix (sometime hype is less than the truth)
          Randy California (Spirit)
          Carlos Santana
          June Millington (Fanny - inf**kingcredible!)
          recent:
          Patty Larkin
          I am not an a**hole. I am a hemorrhoid. I irritate a**holes!
          Procrastination: Forward planning to insure there is something to do tomorrow.
          Derails threads faster than a pocket nuke.

          Comment


          • #6
            Here's another of my top ten: Stevie Ray Vaughan. Just because I'm listening to him right now.

            Pity he got slam-dunked to death near Alpine Valley after he pulled his life back together.
            Knowledge is power. Power corrupts. Study hard. Be evil.

            "I never said I wasn't a horrible person."--Me, almost daily

            Comment


            • #7
              Yngwie Malmsteen goes on my list.

              Also, you might be surprised at how good Prince is on a guitar. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifp_SVrlurY

              Comment


              • #8
                Quoth TheSHAD0W View Post
                Yngwie Malmsteen goes on my list.
                Didn't he change his middle name to "Fucking"?

                Cookies for the reference.
                Knowledge is power. Power corrupts. Study hard. Be evil.

                "I never said I wasn't a horrible person."--Me, almost daily

                Comment


                • #9
                  You know who you guys should ask this question to? GUITAR PLAYERS.

                  If you ask the professionals, the name you're most likely to hear mentioned is JOE SATRIANI, the man that taught Metallica's Kirk Hammet how to play!
                  "Eventually one outgrows the fairy tales of childhood, belief in Santa and the Easter Bunny, and believing that SCs are even capable of imagining themselves in our position."
                  --StanFlouride

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Yeah, I was gonna say Satriani. This list is not complete without him.

                    Or Steve Vai.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Quoth draggar View Post
                      Terry Kath (Chicago). His life was cut short and people remember him more for his addictive baritone voice, he was also a great guitar player. Terry played the guitar like any of us breathe and he is also credited for being one of the (if not the) first people to "shred" (a.k.a. shredder) their guitar.
                      I was going to say Terry Kath as well. Too bad he accidentally shot himself...otherwise things would have been different. Here he is doing Uptown with Chicago in 1977...about 11 months before he died. IIRC, that tune is off Chicago's 11 album. Another Kath tune on that album was Mississippi Delta City Blues (the horns are awesome!)
                      Aerodynamics are for people who can't build engines. --Enzo Ferrari

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Quoth Jack T. Chance View Post
                        If you ask the professionals, the name you're most likely to hear mentioned is JOE SATRIANI, the man that taught Metallica's Kirk Hammet how to play!
                        Quoted for truth. "Satchmo" is a phenomenal player, as well as a damn good songwriter. (just ask Coldplay )

                        The other name I came up with is Steve Vai. Go to YouTube and look for "Steve Vai Crossroads duel". Blues guitarist Ry Cooder played all of the Karate Kid's blues but Vai played the classical part (as well as his own part). When he was working with Frank Zappa, people in the audience would bring sheets of music for him to play... music not writen for guitar. And he would play it.

                        Honorable mentions: Paul Gilbert, Joe Bonamassa, John Petrucci, Herman Li and Sam Totman (of Dragonforce, maybe not best but fastest), and there's probably a dozen more I can't think of right now.
                        "Kamala the Ugandan Giant" 1950-2020 • "Bullet" Bob Armstrong 1939-2020 • "Road Warrior Animal" 1960-2020 • "Zeus" Tiny Lister Jr. 1958-2020 • "Hacksaw" Butch Reed 1954-2021 • "New Jack" Jerome Young 1963-2021 • "Mr. Wonderful" Paul Orndorff 1949-2021 • "Beautiful" Bobby Eaton 1958-2021 • Daffney 1975-2021

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          What no love for David Gilmour?

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Quoth Evil Queen View Post
                            Oh jeeze, you have to ask?!

                            Jimmy Hendrix all the way.
                            Quoth dalesys View Post
                            That I've seen?
                            Jimi Hendrix (sometime hype is less than the truth)
                            Carlos Santana
                            Hendrix and Santana - I'll put on the list. Hendrix, well, because he is god. Santana - he's done a great job of combining Latin music with rock and he is also one of the consistent players.

                            Quoth TheSHAD0W View Post
                            Yngwie Malmsteen goes on my list.

                            Also, you might be surprised at how good Prince is on a guitar. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifp_SVrlurY
                            Quoth Irving Patrick Freleigh View Post
                            Didn't he change his middle name to "Fucking"?

                            Cookies for the reference.
                            How the HELL did I forget him?? And yes he did change his middle name to that. He was the master of speed metal though the 80's.

                            Quoth mikoyan29 View Post
                            What no love for David Gilmour?
                            He's very good and unique but I don't think I would put him in league with Page or the others that have come out on this list.

                            Quoth protege View Post
                            I was going to say Terry Kath as well. Too bad he accidentally shot himself...otherwise things would have been different. Here he is doing Uptown with Chicago in 1977...about 11 months before he died. IIRC, that tune is off Chicago's 11 album. Another Kath tune on that album was Mississippi Delta City Blues (the horns are awesome!)

                            Pull out the Carnegie Hall album and listen to the ballet. 'Nuff said.
                            Last edited by draggar; 02-12-2010, 10:12 AM.
                            Quote Dalesys:
                            ... as in "Ifn thet dawg comes at me, Ima gonna shutz ma panz!"

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              David Gilmour is at least as good as Jimmy Page if not better. He is definately one of the better blues guitarists for rock. But then I'm biased. His style definately meshes for Floyd (sadly he doesn't.... )

                              But if I were going to do a list it would probably have:
                              Hendrix
                              Santana
                              Clapton
                              Gilmour
                              Steve Vai (I love Zappa)

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X