Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Not sure where this belongs, but...

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Not sure where this belongs, but...

    OK, as many of you know from my signature and my posts, I am engaged, and a teenager.

    For valentines day, I bought my fiance an engagement ring. Her gift to me, in addition to chocolates, was that we could go public about our engagement, which we've been keeping secret since December. Now, for the record, I rebel against my parents all the time, I resent that they still feel they have a right to tell me what to do when I'm months away from moving out and being legally my own person, I cheat them, I deceive them, and I bend the truth almost to the breaking point, but that's it, almost. I hate outright lying to them, and it's been a real pain in my ass keeping this a secret without doing just that.

    Based on how they had each been acting, we expected her parents to handle it well and respect that we were willing to talk to them over this weekend when we had time to sit down and discuss it openly, while we expected my mother to go ballistic.

    When we announced to my parents, as expected, Dad sat off to the side and laughed, and mom started honing in on us, but she was far more civil and respectful than I had ever hoped.

    When we told hers, they seemed very calm, respectful, and OK with it, and I thought that they had taken it well. I went home for the night happy.

    When I got into school this mourning, I found my finace crying. Apparently, once I had left, her parents had called her into their room, and had started giving her about twelve simultaneous lectures about how she should have come to them first, how it was too soon, and all that. Now, for one thing, anything they can say to her, they can say in front of me, and in fact, if she is being attacked (as she was by the end of it), it's kinda my job to protect her. Foul one: Waiting for me to leave. If you don't want me to consider you evil manipulative, crazy asswipes, then don't perform the actions that would make me think that, jerkwad, don't simply covering it up by making yourself look calm until I leave.

    Now, the argument escalated, and when she told them that we have no intention of getting married until at least two years from now, after we've been living together a while, they flipped out. Apparently they were surprised that a teenage girl wouldn't want to live with her parents all the way through college, and that caused them to go postal. Foul Two: If you claim to be the 'cool parents', who know that teenagers are teenagers, and how they're likely to feel about things, then don't be surprised when your daughter tells you she'd rather live with her fiance than with you once the two of them can get the money together to rent an apartment. Foul Three: Do not scream, at 11:00 at night, loud enough to wake everyone in a five block radius "GET OUT!" simply because you've run out of logical arguments to make and need more time to think. Foul Four: Do not then wake your daughter, who has just finished crying herself to sleep, up at 12:30 AM because you've finally figured out more ammunition to use on her.

    So guess what happened? That's right, they did it. They woke her up and continued bitching her out. It very quickly stopped being a reasonable debate, and after that it quickly ceased to be a logical, reasonable lecture. It quickly became a game of scream at your daughter for an hour about how bad a kid she is, despite the fact that her younger brother gives you more trouble on an average day than she's given you in her worst year. They continued this way for another hour. Foul five: I don't care how upset you are, there is no excuse to call your own daughter "white trailer trash", or to let your husband call her worse such names. Foul Six: If you are going to have a 'I'm a cool parent you can come to about anything' policy, then when your daughter tries to be responsible and tell you about a big decision like this, it typically isn't a good idea to try to explain to them that their fiance isn't good enough to join your family. Tends to take away from their trust in you, and their faith in said policy.

    Now, finally they've gotten calmed down enough to let her go to sleep. They leave, and, before she goes to school today, they tell her. "Don't tell Shards about this." That's right, foul number one all the f over again, also, Foul Seven: If you would yell at your daughter for lying to you about something because she understated it to such a degree that it deceived you, then asking her to do the same to her fiance does not seem to show that you have her best interests at heart. It sounds more like you are concerned with how he sees you, and therefore don't care if you ask your daughter to do something that does not sound emotionally healthy at all, just as long as nobody sees you for the manipulative, evil, obnoxious, overbearing, idiotic, weak-willed little son-of-a-bitch you are.

    When she finished telling me this, I really just wanted to punch one of them in the face. Fortunately for them, she was having enough of a breakdown that she needed me there, and hurting them wasn't going to help her with the immediate problem. For the record, if she hadn't needed me there, I probably would have cut school to go and put a nice fist sized dent in her father's car, and three to go along with it in his face, minimum.
    "Darling, you are a bitch. I'm joining the Navy." -Cinema Guy 4/30/2009

  • #2
    I don't know you, you don't know me. So, please excuse me if I'm overstepping my bounds here.

    I would suggest not getting married until both of you graduate college.

    I would also suggest getting over any resentment you have towards her parents right now. Because you're going to have to deal with them for the majority of your life. It's far, far better to have a good relationship with the in-laws.
    "Always stand near the door." -- Doctor Who

    Kuya's Kitchen -- Cooking, Cooking Gadgets, and Food Related Blather from a Transplanted Foodie

    Comment


    • #3
      Yeah, it sounds like they seriously over-reacted. But be glad that you didn't go punch him or his car, it's better in the long run. It sounds to me like they need some serious family counseling.

      a) you did tell them, even if it wasn't as soon as they thought you should
      b) you have demonstrated that you have thought about this & made plans, not rushing into things
      c) while they obviously don't approve or like you two living together, it does mean that when you do get married you'll know what you're getting into (no surprises like 'he does what in the shower?')
      I'm sorry, the person to whom you were speaking has been replaced by a recording. Please leave your message at the sound of the beep.

      Comment


      • #4
        I know well the anxiety you felt telling the parental units. I also dreaded telling my parents when I got engaged mostly because I knew the lectures I would get from them about finishing school first. (Though for me it's college ) Like with you, surprisingly my parents took it really well.

        I am sorry to hear that her's didn't take it well at all, and I agree that if they're going to claim being "cool" that they should perhaps act it and be thankful that their daughter found a wonderful person. One that isn't going to rush out to Vegas to get married, but wait a couple of years to become more financially stable.

        Maybe sitting down and talking with her parents again might be worth considering? You don't neccissarily have to let on that she told you anything, just simply say "I understand you might have some worries that we're rushing into things. I wanted to sit with you and discuss what we're planning and take your suggestions." Perhaps letting them know that you are willing to consider their ideas and concerns will help them calm down a bit. It wouldn't hurt to do the same with your parents as well.

        I hope everything works out the best for you!

        Comment


        • #5
          OK, here's an update, for those of you who care.

          we sat down with my parents in order to discuss it further. During the conversation, her parents showed up, uninvited and unannounced, and invited themselves in to take part in the discussion. They acted all nice, warm and fuzzy while they were there, again like they had when we first told them before I left.

          Apparently, because my father said that he wanted to 'de-escalate' the argument, as opposed to forcing us to call it off, they decided to call him 'an idiot that shards has wrapped around his finger.' to my fiance's face. Also, apparently because they weren't screaming at me the whole time, they 'don't care about their kid, and aren't fit to be parents.'

          Also, apparently they have decided that I am 'manipulative, and not to be trusted.'

          I really, really am not becoming endeared toward the family I'm marrying into.
          "Darling, you are a bitch. I'm joining the Navy." -Cinema Guy 4/30/2009

          Comment


          • #6
            Ok, just because your parents are willing to talk to the two of you like adults doesn't mean they are wrapped around your finger, or bad parents ...grrr, that just ticked me off. Maybe that, afterall, is the big issue here. Her parents are thinking of you as kids. You're not, you're adults--based on maturity not age--and are capable of making adult decisions IMO. I need to find me a stick.....

            My ranting aside, just remember to offer your support to your fiance. Lots of hugs and comforting words! Try not to rant and rave at her about her parents too much in her presence. Being stuck in the middle would do nothing but upset her more. Which I'm sure you already know Again, I wish you all the best. Hopefully things will look up soon.

            Comment


            • #7
              Their behavior towards your fiancee sounds like a textbook case of verbal and emotional abuse. She should consider staying at a friend's house, and I encourage her to call the cops or your school's social worker the next time they scream at her. Also, if they ever touch her in anger, even if they're just grabbing her arm or pushing her into a chair, she should get out and call 911. Far better to be safe than sorry.
              "If everyone is thinking alike, someone isn't thinking." - George Patton

              "If you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it well enough." - Albert Einstein

              Comment


              • #8
                I agree that their behavior is abusive. They are clearly upset about their daughter's engagement, and while they may have good reasons to be, like fears that she'll skip college or get pregnant too young, they're not expressing those fears. They're expressing anger and a lack of self control.

                Can you try to talk them into going to counseling with you and their daughter? If not, you and your fiancee should go to counseling together. Look around and find a therapist who does a lot of family therapy with families involving high school age kids. She needs professional advice to help her deal with the toxic situation that she's now in. Whether it can be repaired is the first question to answer. Can she live with them, or does she need to try to find a friend or another relative she can stay with? If she's being abused and she's not able to leave their home, it may be necessary to tell her parents that you've decided they're right and you will continue dating but call off the engagement for now. If you have to lie to keep her safe, do it.

                No matter how mature you feel- and believe me, I'm still with my high school sweetheart against all the predictions of my family, so I know- you're not legally an adult yet, and neither is she. This is probably the worst obstacle you've faced as a couple so far, but if you stay together for life, it won't be the worst you'll ever face. If you have to swallow your pride and take off your engagement rings, do it. It won't be long before you ARE adults and you do have the money and flexibility to live together and let her parents just darn well get used to their new son in law.
                My basic dog food advice - send a pm if you need more.

                Saydrah's leaving the nest advice + packing list live here.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Quoth Saydrah View Post
                  I agree that their behavior is abusive. They are clearly upset about their daughter's engagement, and while they may have good reasons to be, like fears that she'll skip college or get pregnant too young, they're not expressing those fears. They're expressing anger and a lack of self control.

                  Can you try to talk them into going to counseling with you and their daughter? If not, you and your fiancee should go to counseling together. Look around and find a therapist who does a lot of family therapy with families involving high school age kids. She needs professional advice to help her deal with the toxic situation that she's now in. Whether it can be repaired is the first question to answer. Can she live with them, or does she need to try to find a friend or another relative she can stay with? If she's being abused and she's not able to leave their home, it may be necessary to tell her parents that you've decided they're right and you will continue dating but call off the engagement for now. If you have to lie to keep her safe, do it.

                  No matter how mature you feel- and believe me, I'm still with my high school sweetheart against all the predictions of my family, so I know- you're not legally an adult yet, and neither is she. This is probably the worst obstacle you've faced as a couple so far, but if you stay together for life, it won't be the worst you'll ever face. If you have to swallow your pride and take off your engagement rings, do it. It won't be long before you ARE adults and you do have the money and flexibility to live together and let her parents just darn well get used to their new son in law.
                  I completely forgot to put that in the update. We already did. They forced her to return the ring, and so I took it, and have been keeping it safe to give back to her later. They believe we're just dating, and they've been telling her that although they would never tell her who to or not to date, I'm not a good person, and they'll support her completely if she decides to break up with me.

                  Now, I know a lot of people are going to tell me that blood is thicker than water, and in my own case, I agree that although I have my disagreements with my parents and cousins, they're still my family, but my fiance has told me that she wants minimal or less contact with her parents starting as soon as she moves into my apartment during college. I'd do anything for her, and despite them being her family, I've seen how they treat her, and I wholeheartedly believe that those blood ties only go so far.

                  Sorry, didn't mean to rant...
                  "Darling, you are a bitch. I'm joining the Navy." -Cinema Guy 4/30/2009

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Blood is thicker than water. That's why it hurts more when one's family is the attackers.

                    I hope you and your fiancee get through this together: remember, only two(?) monthes until y'all can move in together. The time may drag by, but there is light at the end of the tunnel.
                    "If everyone is thinking alike, someone isn't thinking." - George Patton

                    "If you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it well enough." - Albert Einstein

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Quoth Sylvia727 View Post
                      Blood is thicker than water. That's why it hurts more when one's family is the attackers.

                      I hope you and your fiancee get through this together: remember, only two(?) monthes until y'all can move in together. The time may drag by, but there is light at the end of the tunnel.
                      Unfortunately, that isn't the case. We're both going to a local univercity, and it requires that you spend the first year either A: In the dorms, or B: living at home. I'm living in the dorms, and her parents couldn't afford to send her to the dorms even if they weren't as overbearing sons-of-bitches as they are, so close to 14 or 16 months, unfortunately...
                      "Darling, you are a bitch. I'm joining the Navy." -Cinema Guy 4/30/2009

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        changing my post because i read all the updates.

                        I can't really offer great advice... it took me 34.5 years to find "the one" and we're not married or engaged yet. But I do recommend counseling - both a marriage counselor and a clergy member of your faith. they're trained for this kind of thing... especially helping you prepare for what to expect during marriage, from each other, etc. and it never hurts anyway.

                        but... if her parents go back to name calling, waking her up at 1230 am to yell, threating to kick her out... then yes I would really recommend talking to a conselor.

                        and... you've already said that you're planning on waiting a couple of years before you get married. that's probably a pretty good thing at this point. it doesn't sound like they're going to change their minds quickly - especially if they're at the point where they're saying bad things about you. but a couple of years can do good things for calming them down.

                        you've heard it before, but... it's also a good idea to be financially independant from them first. it may make things easier, especially if they don't change their minds.

                        but... i wish you luck & blessings for the marriage


                        And, age itself doesn't always fix things. Mom & Dad had dated for 2 years & got married when she was 26, he was 39 - yet his mother still hated it and tried to break them up, even after the marriage! it wasn't until they had their first baby that she backed off cos "well he has to take care of the baby now". And on Mom's side, her own mother kept trying to pick out guys for her when she was younger... & mom couldn't stand any of them.
                        but despite opposition, they just celebrated their 41st, so obviously they knew they'd made the right choice in getting married.
                        Last edited by PepperElf; 02-20-2008, 07:06 AM.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I have never understood this overwhelming urge to control your children. My parents never did it, and while you obviously want to protect them, when does that mean controlling them?

                          I don't really have any afvice, except to say it's going to be a hard few months for you both, but you need to stick in there. Do wait till after you've finished your education to marry, because it will be harder if you don't, but apart from that if you know you know.
                          Deepak Chopra says, "Fear deprives people of choice. Fear shrinks the world into isolated, defensive enclaves. Fear spirals out of control. Fear makes everyday life seem clouded over with danger.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I know how much discord can occur when parents don't approve.

                            My mothers parent thought that she was 'marrying below herself' and my fathers parents have never accepted my mother, which leads to some interesting Christmas arrangements, please for the sake of your sanity and any future people involved (by that I mean children as/when they happen) get their anger issues and controlling issues sorted, by whatever means, be that counselling or getting the police involved when parents are being abusive (sleep deprivation is a form of torture...).
                            A PSA, if I may, as well as another.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Quoth Shards View Post
                              Unfortunately, that isn't the case. We're both going to a local univercity, and it requires that you spend the first year either A: In the dorms, or B: living at home. I'm living in the dorms, and her parents couldn't afford to send her to the dorms even if they weren't as overbearing sons-of-bitches as they are, so close to 14 or 16 months, unfortunately...
                              Your fiance should talk to someone at your university's residential life department about costs. Most colleges really prefer that their students live on campus, and they may 'go the extra mile' for her. Her high school guidance counselor may also be able to help.

                              I had an opposite situation. My family loved my 'sweetheart' and wanted us to get married right away. But he was abusive in a number of ways. It took 18 months, graduating, and a long talk with Mama, but I was able to break it off. He harrassed me off and on for 6 months after that, and finally left me alone. Best thing I ever did.

                              Stick it out. Always darkest before the dawn and all that jazz.
                              "Even arms dealers need groceries." ~ Ziva David, NCIS

                              Tony: "Everyone's counting on you, just do what you do best."
                              Abby: "Dance?" ~ NCIS

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X