In which I get scammed at the bus stop.

[Water]

You have a good heart, Wishful, and I won't fault that, but it's time to get your smarts engaged there, too. In my experience, anyone asking for anything on the street is a scam artist. This is a percentage nearing 100 so close as to not be worth mentioning. The truly needy either know where to go to get help and don't need you giving them stuff in the street or they're too proud to beg in the street for what they need.

Trust me. I had a guy approach me for gas money saying he forgot his wallet only to find out later that he was a scammer by my university's police department. Another guy approached me begging for $7 b/c he was stranded 111 miles away from home and that his dad wasn't answering his phone. Yeah, right . Unless he received the remaining $231 for a taxi or $65 for Greyhound and a taxi ride to the nearest Greyhound terminal, I'm calling him a "scammer".

[XCashier]

I admit that I feel differently about street performers than I do about straight out beggars. If you entertain me, whether it's song, dance, magic tricks, or whatever, I'll support that: you're working for your supper, not just wandering around with your hand out.

Exactly. They're working, thus earning their money. Especially if they're good; some famous artists like Woody Guthrie, Gerry Rafferty and Tracy Chapman started by busking.

[Dreamstalker]

During walk/ride/run 'season', a few enterprising souls will go so far as to use actual pledge sheets (sharp eyes will note that all the handwriting is the exact same, right down to the pledger's 'signatures'--and then guy holding the sheet doesn't look like someone who would be running or riding any real distance, let alone afford athletic shoes or a racing bike).

Also some guys near major bus stops (always Reverend so-and-so) with spiels about an urban youth program. I got taken by one of them when I was younger and far less wise--not a lot of money, but he started basically 'stalking' me when I was in that area so I had to call the cops on his ass. Even less legit-looking than the fake riders.

There used to be a guy wandering the major subway station with some slick-looking laminated literature about...some school or youth thing in the middle east I'd never heard about. Wore a very distinctive jacket so was easy to avoid if you knew about him. I decided to watch him one day (waiting for a train, I had some time to kill) and saw him hook a couple people, then when they left whip out a fat wad of cash from a pocket and start counting it. Transit cops approached him a few minutes later, and I never saw him there again.

[Mr Hero]

I was going into Walgreens for some late night cough syrup needs. A guy outside asked me for money so he could take the bus home. I told him I didn't have any money.

About 5 minutes later, I realized that I do have bus passes. I saw him in the store and offered him the passes. Funny how he said he no longer needed money for the bus.

[WishfulSpirit]

We actually had someone ask for money for dinner once. He really did just want food; we offered to buy him something to eat (were right outside the grocery store), he happily and gratefully accepted. We also wrote down some numbers of local charities that could help him, which he also thanked us for.

I like the approach of giving them exactly what they say they want. Separates those who really need something from scammers. My Church Leadership prof in college had the same policy at his congregation when it came to their benevolence ministry: if you said you needed money for the gas bill, they'd make the check out to the gas company. If you said you had no place to stay on a freezing night, they had hotel vouchers. Need food? Grocery vouchers (other churches had emergency food pantries as well). Nobody just got money.

That's actually why I would give people bus passes. If they really needed to get somewhere, that got them what they needed. Never saw someone trade it before. I'll probably NOT give one to someone who actually asks me, but if I see someone in need, I am not disillusioned enough to not step up. For example, I bet I'll still give a pass to the next person who gets on wearing a hospital bracelet (there's an ER on our route) and is begging the driver for a ride home (Ambulances don't do return service). I'm a softie like that.

[EvilEmpryss]

Either they don't have a car at all, or me making this offer -- in a loud voice so the other people in the station could hear me -- killed their chances of getting any money from them in this round. I love messing with the ones begging for gas money. I suddenly become the most solicitous person in the world.

Your car's a couple of blocks away? No problem, I drive the gas can over to the car.

Your car's in a bad part of town? Let me call the police; they'll escort us back there to make sure you're safe.

It's got engine/transmission/tire problems? Oh, my brother runs a garage here in town. He'll help you out. Let me call him.... (I don't have a brother, much less one that runs a garage, but I have never been called on this one)

For every excuse I get, I counter it, but I have never, in all my life, ever had to actually fill a gas can to take to a car. They always leave empty handed, often fuming over being blocked.

[Monterey Jack]

I've been hit up more than once at gas stations by people who cars supposedly ran out of gas and they just need a few dollars to get some gas to get them to *insert name of next town over*. These people will pester everyone in a gas station for money, but when I reply "Oh, that's terrible! Where's your car? I have a five gallon can in my trunk. I'll fill it up and take it to your car for you" they back off like I pulled a gun on them.

This seems truly stupid...five free gallons of gas? Yeah, it might not be the money they wanted for booze/cigs/drugs, but they're still getting something for free, and that's less money they need to spend on gas that they can use for booze/cigs/drugs. Unless these panhandlers don't have a car at all...

[EvilEmpryss]

I admit that I feel differently about street performers than I do about straight out beggars. If you entertain me, whether it's song, dance, magic tricks, or whatever, I'll support that: you're working for your supper, not just wandering around with your hand out. They may wind up using the money for illicit purposes, but I have a soft spot for the performers. I just make sure I'm not being set up to have my pocket picked while I'm distracted.

I've been hit up more than once at gas stations by people who cars supposedly ran out of gas and they just need a few dollars to get some gas to get them to *insert name of next town over*. These people will pester everyone in a gas station for money, but when I reply "Oh, that's terrible! Where's your car? I have a five gallon can in my trunk. I'll fill it up and take it to your car for you" they back off like I pulled a gun on them.

Funny, that car never seems to be accessible to people with actual gas, just to the owners with money you give them. They won't even take a prepaid gas card (insane considering that damned near everyone needs gas at some point), but I guess a gas card can't be turned back into cash or traded for drugs.

[mathnerd]

My view on panhandlers is a little skewed, as this is my uncle:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leslie_Cochran

Now don't get me wrong, I adored him. He's the only relative of mine who's funeral I could be bothered to attend. I couldn't be bothered to drive 5 minutes to another uncle's funeral, but I paid a fortune for a last minute flight from North Dakota to Austin, TX to be there in the days before Uncle Albert's death and stayed through his funeral.

However, before he transformed into Leslie and moved to Austin, he was a regular panhandler. For a few years when I was a teen, he lived not to far from where my family lived. Once a week he'd show up with a pick up truck load of food and other items that were given to him, which my mother promptly loaded up into her van and donate to a food bank. That was on top of the money he received, which was enough that he stayed in a reasonably nice hotel most nights and drove an older but well-maintained car (it wasn't until a little bit before he moved to Austin that he decided he liked his tricycle and urban camping). Granted, he might have been the exception, and he did put some effort into it. He played his guitar and cracked jokes in an attempt to entertain people into parting with their money. But still, because I know just how much he was given, I'm just not interested in giving my money directly to people on the streets. I'd rather give to established charities.

[MadMike]

I got scammed like that back when I first started working at the job I have now, roughly 25 years ago. I work in the city, and I was walking somewhere to get some lunch. Some guy approached me, and told me he had just been released from the hospital earlier that day, and hadn't had anything to eat all day, and could I spare a few dollars so he could get himself something to eat? I gave him a few dollars and went on my way, feeling a little better about myself because I had helped someone.

A few weeks later, I was walking somewhere for lunch again, and the same guy approached me with the exact same bullshit story. I'm terrible with names and faces, and didn't recognize him, and I guess he scammed so many people, he didn't remember them either. But I remembered his story, and realized he was scamming people. I just mumbled something about not having any money and walked away, feeling my faith in humanity dropping.

[MoonCat]

Some years ago, the cops in my town let people know that most of the panhandlers on the street were well known to the police as alcoholics and drug addicts, and they advised people not to give them money. For a while the stores had a thing going where you could drop change into a collection box that was then given to the homeless shelters, but I think that's gone now. Still, there is a well-known men's shelter within walking distance of the downtown areas the panhandlers favor; and other places as well. I NEVER take my wallet out on the street.

[Monterey Jack]

If someone is truly hungry, they'll accept a gift of food, or at least an offer to take them to the nearest fast food place and buy them a burger and fries or something. If they insist on cash, that money is going towards booze, drugs, cigarettes, or all three. I never, EVER give money to people on the street. At most, I'll drop a few bucks into a Salvation Army bucket near Christmas.

[Slave to the Phone]

I also don't give money to people on the street. I do carry granola bars and bottled water to give away. Also small bags of dog food for those who have dogs with them. It took me a LONG time to learn that most of the people asking for money are probably scammers.

[nutraxfornerves]

Tickets for our light rail system are good for 90 minutes. It's common to see people hanging around the ticket machines, offering to sell a ticket that still has a half hour on it, for half price.

There are also kindly souls who put unexpired tickets on top of the machines after exiting the train, for anyone to take. I have a sneaking hunch that a lot of the entrepreneurs acquire their inventory that way.

[cindybubbles]

I got scammed like that too. A woman asked everyone for $2 for bus fare. I gave her $5, saying that's the smallest bill that I got and I didn't have any change. She said "That's OK!" and darted off. WTH?

I also got scammed by an elderly woman on the subway, again, losing $5. EvilEmpryss, you're right about donating to charities. My family donates money to the church and to ShareLife.