Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

eBay is Serious Business

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Irving Patrick Freleigh
    replied
    Quoth HYHYBT View Post
    So why is eBay changing their feedback rules?

    (It's taken me nine years to get a score of 35)
    Because people who only buy on ebay complained that sellers wait until the buyers leave feedback, so that they can use it as a retaliatory weapon if the buyer leaves them a negative.

    Which is very much a problem of ebay's own creation since they started handing out suspensions for sellers whose feedback scores over a 90-day period place them in the bottom 5% of all sellers doing similar volume (or something like that). If you're a very low-volume seller like myself, it can take as few as 2 negatives (or neutrals, which ebay considers "soft" negatives) to trigger a suspension.

    So what then happened is sellers would suddenly find their accounts restricted, ask Live Help(less) how to get the restrictions lifted, and Live Help(less) would sometimes suggest leaving negatives for buyers who left them negatives, and then offer mutual feedback withdrawal. Anything necessary to get the negative off their record.

    (One more tidbit for the ebayers out there: If you have a problem, go to the Answer Center or the Discussion Boards for help. Avoid Live Help unless you want to be given politely-stated but completely incorrect advice)

    Leave a comment:


  • HYHYBT
    replied
    So why is eBay changing their feedback rules?

    (It's taken me nine years to get a score of 35)

    Leave a comment:


  • draftermatt
    replied
    See all of these reasons is why I gave up on eBay. If I need something I can't find elsewhere I'll go there, but I sell on Craigslist, and buy in stores now.

    It all went downhill when I got banned by eBay before they tried to contact me about an item I was selling (and it was the 2nd time I had listed said item). Then my father got a negative because he left one. The guy didn't ship, then sent a refund thru paypal (my father never had or has had a paypal account) so he left a negative since he now had money in a non-existant account. The guy left negative back since "I gave a refund" Dude, you just randomly popped up and said "Sorry, forgot to ship it, here's a refund to paypal" Didn't ask, nothing.

    Leave a comment:


  • wagegoth
    replied
    There are buyers who don't want to follow the rules, who want you to ship to a different address than the registered one, who don't understand that even though Canada is our friendly neighbor to the North, I now have to fill out a five-part form to ship anything there, and if it takes more time I'm going to charge a little extra for shipping and handling to Canada.

    Some buyers seem to assume that when they buy on eBay it's like buying from a Sears catalog, and they can simply return the item if it isn't quite what they wanted or it didn't arrive within three days after they "ordered" it.

    Some buyers absolutely do not read any of the information you post in the description. I'm always very clear about the condition of items, including the packaging, even if it's not a collectible, even when I don't think it will matter (like the cover of a sewing pattern), because people will whine that the corner of the pattern was slightly separated.

    As a buyer, I don't order from the mass sellers in Asia. I have ordered from indy sellers in Japan and Europe for collectibles. I've also sold to them. This is why I'm very honest in my listings and I expect complete honesty in my sellers. I ask lots of questions before I bid.

    And I thoroughly check feedback, and if it's not high and 100%, I check why it's not. I read the comments for patterns of behavior. Sometimes, I've found a seller is just new and they got some ass who tried to bully them. I'll read through the feedback of the buyers who have left negatives to see what kind of feedback they have. Often, they have some wild comments left on them.

    Unfortunately, with the changes on eBay, I'm re-evaluating selling there. I was never a big seller; I didn't do it to make money, just to clean out extra items and clear space in my storage, so it's not a necessity. There are some pagan auction sites that I might start listing on, so I'll have to check those out.

    It's too bad. eBay was so cool, until they got greedy. Greedy makes you stupid.

    Leave a comment:


  • Seshat
    replied
    Quoth Boozy View Post
    I am confused. Why is the buyer's obligation not finished after payment, or the seller's not finished when they ship? If the item is received in good time and in good condition, is the transaction not finished at that point?
    Assuming that the item is received as advertised, in good time, and that neither party is sucky or a scammer - the transaction is then finished. You're absolutely right.

    It is nice - and strongly recommended - for both parties to then leave feedback. Something like 'item was received promptly and is exactly as advertised, communication was good' is good for the buyer to leave, and 'payment was prompt, communication was good' is good for the seller to leave. That covers the most critical aspects of a non-sucky transaction with no problems.

    Does that clear the confusion?

    If there were problems, then both parties have an obligation to communicate, and to come up with a mutually reasonable solution. Again, I'm pretty sure that's what you'd assume (and would do) - you've come across as a sensible sort of person on these boards.

    Anyway: add sucky unreasonableness and intentional scamming, and you end up with sellers who are just as worried about buyers, as you have buyers worried about sellers.

    Leave a comment:


  • Rapscallion
    replied
    There are a few signs that this thread is becoming heated, folks. Keep an eye on the issues, and not each other, please.

    Rapscallion

    Leave a comment:


  • PuckishOne
    replied
    Quoth Andara Bledin View Post
    I don't assume anyone is a scammer. But I can't tell scammers from honest people, so covering my ass is just common sense.

    Doing business anywhere will accrue a certain amount of loss due to theft and fraud. The intelligent thing to do is to be as informed as possible and do what is reasonable to prevent what you can.
    Excellent advice, be it on eBay or anyplace in the retail world.

    And now for your friendly mod reminder to please keep this civil - no personal attacks, no name-calling, lest we turn out to be as bad as the SCs we're here to vent about. Thanks.

    Leave a comment:


  • Andara Bledin
    replied
    Quoth poofy_puff View Post
    The thing about it is, the seller would not send the item out until clearing payment, but once the item is paid for, there is nothing the buyer can do except WAIT for the seller to ship.
    Technically, other than cash or a wire transfer, there is no such thing as a "cleared payment." PayPal payments can be charged back both by PayPal and by a credit card provider, even if they were legitimate. Checks can be either just bad (bank will clear checks at 2 weeks, then reverse the check at the 6-week mark for fraud: it's happened to my company more than once) or have a stop payment on them. There is a high incidence of money order forgeries, and the number of really good cashiers check forgeries is going up.

    All of the real power, for anyone who does their homework, is in the buyer's court. That the seller has the power is mostly an illusion. Mostly because most people are honest and don't understand/consider all of the crappy things that scammers and just plain sucky people pull on sellers pretty much every minute on eBay and elsewhere.

    One thing that is often not understood is that just because payment has been submitted (and accepted by the bank) does not guarantee that the payment was actually valid. My company has had bad checks and money orders take as long as two months before being caught by the bank and charged back to us.

    This type of scenario (which is unfortunately rather common) is exactly the sort of situation that is a good use of a Follow-up comment in Feedback as it currently stands. With the whole "checkmark for payment submitted" format, there is no option that I'm aware of to let future sellers know about fraudulent payments made and not caught until after the deadline set by eBay.


    Quoth poofy_puff View Post
    But you said not to assume anything, so why assume that everyone is an SC (or scammer) if only a small percentage really are? If you feel that way, just don't use eBay.
    I don't assume anyone is a scammer. But I can't tell scammers from honest people, so covering my ass is just common sense.

    Doing business anywhere will accrue a certain amount of loss due to theft and fraud. The intelligent thing to do is to be as informed as possible and do what is reasonable to prevent what you can.

    ^-.-^

    Leave a comment:


  • poofy_puff
    replied
    I didn't mean ALWAYS assume EVERY customer is not an SC. Look at the original conversation, I was talking about a typical scenario, where the buyer is not an SC. I am not an SC Buyer, and I'd like to think there are others like myself out there.

    As such, once the buyer has paid and seller receives payment, the ball is in the SELLER's court to fulfill the transaction. If there is something wrong, then the buyer should try to work it out before leaving negative feedback. Furthermore, leaving feedback is not REQUIRED by eBay. So it is not an "obligation" that the buyer "owes" the seller (and vice-versa).


    The thing about it is, the seller would not send the item out until clearing payment, but once the item is paid for, there is nothing the buyer can do except WAIT for the seller to ship. At that point, the seller holds all the cards. So I am asking for these dozens of examples that you say you have. Not where a buyer has done the WRONG (SC) thing, but where the buyer still owes the seller something after paying for their item. I have been disappointed (as a buyer) by sellers, but never (as a seller) by any of my buyers. I have also taken advantage of eBay and PayPal's buyer protection facilities when necessary, and got refunded for the PURCHASES THAT WERE NEVER SENT AFTER I PAID. There was one time when I was re-selling some shoes I bought which didn't fit me (See? MY mistake not ordering the correct size, but the seller did everything right so I'm not being an SC), and one prospective buyer was asking all kinds of questions about "shipping costs". I was using the eBay shipping calculator where you enter your zip-code and the weight of the package, but at the time it was an external link to the Post Office web page, and they had just changed the system to reflect the distance traveled in the price. So this lady didn't want to hear of it. She accused me of scamming her (without even placing a bid) and said that it doesn't matter where the package is going, only the weight and size matters. After arguing a little and realizing that I didn't want to be involved in a transaction with this person, I simply sent her a link to the Post Office shipping calculator (which was in the auction listing already) and told her to please not bid on any of my auctions, ever.



    I'm not worried about it; I have been using eBay just fine and it's like any other store where sometimes you have to go back and resolve an issue after you leave with your purchase. But you said not to assume anything, so why assume that everyone is an SC (or scammer) if only a small percentage really are? If you feel that way, just don't use eBay.

    BTW, I did say I was going to ask for the refund from Mr. Hong-Kong. I fell off the turnip truck last week, not last night. If you read the entire message, you would see that. But thank you for the free advice.
    Last edited by poofy_puff; 03-18-2008, 06:23 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Andara Bledin
    replied
    Quoth hotelnpa View Post
    I just wonder if the positives this lady is receiving is really positive. Maybe some are leaving positives because they are afraid of this woman.
    Probably a lot, which is silly, since buyer Feedback is meaningless except in how it relates to seller Feedback. Basically, Feedback left for buyers will tell you a lot about how a seller is. One of the many reasons the new Feedback changes are going to suck for buyers as much as sellers. But they'll be great for scammers.

    Quoth CancelMyService View Post
    What's funny is she's all "LOOK AT MY FEEDBACK, WHY WOULD I RIP YOU OFF??" when her feedback (which is probably 95% positive at least) has several "mutually withdrawn" feedbacks where she obviously bullied people into retracting negative feedback left on her.
    95% is awful. Seriously. Generally speaking, if the person has a high enough number (say over 300), then anything less than 98% is a serious red flag. I usually use a baseline of 1% Negative and 1% Neutral for my purchases. Although I actually read comments to see if any recent Non-Positives were undeserved and check Feedback left for erratic responses.

    Quoth Boozy View Post
    Why is the buyer's obligation not finished after payment, or the seller's not finished when they ship? If the item is received in good time and in good condition, is the transaction not finished at that point?
    Quoth poofy_puff View Post
    I disagree. Let's assume the buyer is NOT a SC. What more do you expect the buyer to do for the seller once the item has been paid for, other than waiting and leaving appropriate feedback? The if-then logic situation shown above is not accurate, because if the item arrives broken or gets lost in the mail (assuming that there was insurance and DC), then the seller has additional obligations which do not require reciprocation in kind by the buyer. For example, I buy from you and it gets broken, you make a claim for insurance. I don't have to pay you anything else. All I owe you really is positive feedback for resolving the situation in a timely manner.

    I'm going through this right now. I bought a cheap audio-video accessory from a seller out of Hong-Kong, and they just wrote back to me like this:

    Sorry for late, we think there must be some error and item can't reach you by now. If you promise no negative/neutral feedback and no complaint/dispute against us, we agree to reship. You can write to me with your delivery address to indicate you consent to our reship ( no tracking number). If you can't wait long and need refund, let me know. ( we need a good rating )
    First off, assuming that a buyer is not an SC is a dangerous proposition. Approximately 1% of all eBay transactions are scammers looking to make a quick buck. Some areas are more likely, with electronics being high-scam waters on both sides.

    Never assume anything. Wait for confirmation and cover your ass in the meantime.

    Second, if an item arrives broken, then, through no fault of the buyer, the buyer still has something they need to do. They need to contact the seller. So, even though the buyer is fine, they still have an obligation in the sale. Would you rather a buyer got their nice shiny "paid" sticker, then turned around and left you Negative Feedback because the post office crushed their package? It happens all the time.

    If you want more examples of how it's not over for the buyer just because they paid, just ask. I've got dozens. Just because a person can use PayPal right after the sale doesn't mean they are any sort of reasonable individual, and Feedback should reflect the entire sale for both parties.

    As for your Hong Kong guy, and ask for the refund. And you can even promise that you won't report him to eBay for it. After all, if you get the refund, there's no reason to report him.

    I'm extra careful when dealing with overseas sellers because there are so many fly-by-night operations and you can't go after them when they're on a different continent. Hard enough when it's just a different country.

    ^-.-^

    Leave a comment:


  • poofy_puff
    replied
    Quote:
    Quoth greensinestro View Post
    The buyer usually has to pay for their merchandise before it is even shipped out, so to me, the buyer has fulfilled their end of the bargain, leaving it up to the seller to fulfill theirs.

    As a former ebay seller, this is the stupidest thing I've ever heard. If the buyer's obligation is done when they pay for an item, then the seller's obligation is done when they ship the item out. You and I both know that's untrue.
    ------------------------------------------------------

    [I have bought and sold on eBay and have 100% positive, never left a negative, only neutral instead, for others]

    I disagree. Let's assume the buyer is NOT a SC. What more do you expect the buyer to do for the seller once the item has been paid for, other than waiting and leaving appropriate feedback? The if-then logic situation shown above is not accurate, because if the item arrives broken or gets lost in the mail (assuming that there was insurance and DC), then the seller has additional obligations which do not require reciprocation in kind by the buyer. For example, I buy from you and it gets broken, you make a claim for insurance. I don't have to pay you anything else. All I owe you really is positive feedback for resolving the situation in a timely manner.

    I'm going through this right now. I bought a cheap audio-video accessory from a seller out of Hong-Kong, and they just wrote back to me like this:

    Sorry for late, we think there must be some error and item can't reach you by now. If you promise no negative/neutral feedback and no complaint/dispute against us, we agree to reship. You can write to me with your delivery address to indicate you consent to our reship ( no tracking number). If you can't wait long and need refund, let me know. ( we need a good rating )


    ---------------------------------------

    I think I'm going to ask for a refund and get one at Radio Shack. But my point is, how is it that MY obligation to this seller has NOT been fulfilled (so far)? (It is Item #150210332627 if anyone cares enough to check).

    Leave a comment:


  • Boozy
    replied
    Quoth Irving Patrick Freleigh View Post
    If the buyer's obligation is done when they pay for an item, then the seller's obligation is done when they ship the item out. You and I both know that's untrue.
    I am confused. Why is the buyer's obligation not finished after payment, or the seller's not finished when they ship? If the item is received in good time and in good condition, is the transaction not finished at that point?

    Does this Feedback thing have something to do with it?

    Please pardon my ignorance; I've never used eBay before so I'm a little lost here.

    Leave a comment:


  • powerboy
    replied
    I have bought 1 item on Ebay. I had received it earlier than expected, so I left a positive review. I don't like how newer people, does not have a chance on Ebay. I like Amazon and the others a lot more.

    Leave a comment:


  • CrazedClerkthe2nd
    replied
    A lot of ebay sellers try to act tough but that's mainly because they have computers to hide behind. Stick to your guns, they'll back down.

    I had someone open a dispute on me once, I guess they felt because my feedback was low (less than 50) I wasn't too familiar with ebay or Paypal. Wrong.

    I stood firm right through the dispute process until finally he dropped it claiming he "hadn't realized he already had the item"

    Suuuuure. Jerk.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lil Bunny
    replied
    Ok after reading all of this, I must say I have learned a lot!

    Does a lot of this apply to Amazon as well (rules wise...you know what I mean)? I had a good run over there aside from a few idiots.

    One was over seas which specified up to 2 months on shipping. This person left me negative reviews and very intimidating emails because it wasn't there in the US terms of 2 to 4 weeks. I flat out told him the date I mailed it (two days after they ordered) and the expected receivable date. As I was tracking it, if it wasn't there by Amazons specified shipping time frame, I'd refund their money or get them a new one. You'd think I'd have insulted his mother. Guess what got there 4 days later. Ahem.

    But, it really turned me off of selling books online even though I was doing really good at it. I was probably a bit more honest than necessary but my record was immaculate with them til the two people who thought they could bully me. Seriously, how do you downgrade a book that was already at "Well used"? I mentioned all the dog tags, highlighting, notes in the margin, warn covers and broke spine. What more do you want?? And at .50 cents? Seriously!!

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X