"If it weren't for the potential of people being crazy enough to show up at my front door and stab me, I wouldn't have a problem with that (not so likely for customers hundreds of miles away, but the locals call in too and the can be just as nuts)."
Well, right, but the reality is that that problem DOES exsist and you DO have a problem with giving out your number, and with very good reason.
I don't give the zip out, either. Not that I think there's any harm in giving it out, it's just that I do not want to encourage polling at cash registers. I do not like the practice of info collecting on demand at registers. So I simply give no info out, regardless.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
My privacy is being violated!
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
I never give out personal info for a basic purchase either. My husband is in an unusual line of work (a perfectly legitimate one, I should add) that requires us to be very cautious about who has our address and phone numbers. The cashiers have never been rude about it, probably because I have never been rude in my refusal. But I get these looks that say, "What? You're saying NO? How odd." They must be so used to people just mindlessly spewing out all their private information. My husband says I would be amazed at the amount of information people will give up about themselves, just because someone ASKS.Quoth RecoveringKinkoid View PostIf I notice it's a manager ringing me up, I will politely voice my displeasure at being asked for personal info, but otherwise, I just say "No, I don't give that out." And frequently get treated like I just called someone's mom a nasty name for it.
Sometimes they just ask for my postal (zip) code. That's so they can figure out where people are coming from, and if they should put a store closer to that area. If I would like to see that particular store in my neighbourhood, I sometimes share that info. (I'm one of the few residents of North America that DOESN'T have a Starbucks within spitting distance of their home. Shamefully, I'd like one closer. Preferably in my basement.)
Leave a comment:
-
If it weren't for the potential of people being crazy enough to show up at my front door and stab me, I wouldn't have a problem with that (not so likely for customers hundreds of miles away, but the locals call in too and the can be just as nuts).Quoth RecoveringKinkoid View Post
Yeah, actually. I have asked persistant clerks if I could have their home information. Fair's fair and all that.
Same as my phone number. It's bad enough dealing with a lot of the jerks I get that call in the customer care line. I would rather not become somebody's pet customer service rep.
Leave a comment:
-
"Shouldn't that person be entitled to theirs as well? "You have my number, address, etc, so why can't I have yours?"
Yeah, actually. I have asked persistant clerks if I could have their home information. Fair's fair and all that.
Strangely, nobody's given their info to me. Imagine that.
Leave a comment:
-
I get this a lot myself. I used to particularly get it working in phone repair and customer service. My favorites were the ones who would claim that caller ID violates a person's privacy if their number is unlisted, plus many of these people feel a credit for paying for that each month is due to them. Yet, why did they never feel it wrong to have the number of the person they were calling? Shouldn't that person be entitled to theirs as well? "You have my number, address, etc, so why can't I have yours?"
In repair, we actually would get calls on that. "I want to have my phone looked at. It's giving out my name and number on other people's caller ID when I call out, and I have an unpublished phone number." And then, when you would look at this dingbat's records, he also had caller ID! So, it was all right for him to identify his calls, but he didn't want people to identify him!
Leave a comment:
-
"I don't care where you live, I'm just required to ask for whatever reason the corporate office asks."
I'm one of these people who don't give that out. I realize you are required to ask for it, so I'm never nasty to the clerk. But I'm not required to give it out, so unless I feel a store has a reasonable need for it, I don't give it out. I don't give out any info at cash registers, actually, as I'm not there to fill out a marketing or demographics poll. I'm there to exchange goods for money.
If I'm paying with a check, I'll give it. And if I'm having delivery or whatever done, I'll give it. But just to buy a box of nails or a book or a pair of socks? Forget it. It IS a privacy thing, and I have a right to decide what I do with my personal info.
Not a single clerk has been able to tell me why that info is collected. Not one. And sometimes I do ask, just out of curiosity. Usually they look at me, stunned, then say "uhhh....I don't know" or "the register wants it" or "so we can send you coupons" (interesting, didn't know the mail worked that way
. Not a single one of them will come out and admit it's for marketing purposes. Probably they don't know. That's okay. Like I said, I don't really care about the why of it.
If I notice it's a manager ringing me up, I will politely voice my displeasure at being asked for personal info, but otherwise, I just say "No, I don't give that out." And frequently get treated like I just called someone's mom a nasty name for it.
90 percent of the time, the info asked for is not needed for the transaction. More people should stop just blithely giving out their personal info like unthinking cows and sheep just because they are asked for it. These same people complain when their lives are interrupted by telemarketers. They need to think about why that might happen.
Leave a comment:
-
I can do you one better.Quoth Parts_Drone View PostI'm sure some of the rest of you here has had this happen, you ask someone for their name and phone number for some reason (in this case so I could process a return) and they flip out and claim it's an invasion of privacy. A couple days ago a customer did just that, uttering such gems as "theres something called the privacy act you know!". So I simply told the customer to put his name and signature and make up a phone number if it made him feel better, crisis averted
.
"Can I have your Social Security Number please?"
"Oh, sure, it's xxx-xx-xxxx."
"Thank you, can I have your phone number please?"
"WHAT?!?! I'M NOT GIVING YOU THAT, YOU'LL SELL IT! YOU CAN'T ASK FOR THAT, IT'S ILLEGALLLL!!!!!"
O.o
Leave a comment:
-
Reminds me of the rash of clients lately who think that HIPAA laws prevent them from giving me ANY information about the patient, even though I explain that they indicated that insurance should be billed, but did not provide us with the insurance policy numbers.Quoth Juwl View Post"Yes, sir/Ma'am/Other, there is a thing called the Privacy Act, it makes it illegal for me to give your information to others without your consent for me to do so. I don't see how this affects my collecting the info for our system, as it's the only way I'll be able to send out the item you requested."
Leave a comment:
-
Yet, paradoxically, these are the same customers who don't understand why I can't give them phone numbers from their call records, have to ask them to confirm their address for me since I can't read it to them, or give them their own mobile phone #. Because these things are all considered "personal" information and just in case you aren't who you say you are, we can't give it out.Quoth Gravekeeper View PostI like the paranoia flip outs. The caller is perfectly normal the entire call till you ask for the one red flag piece of information. It could be their number, their address, their last name.....but the second you ask for it they go "WHY DO YOU NEED THAT!??"
All SC's in unison: "Well, that's just stupid!"
No, it's protecting you. There have been so many times a violent, unstable ex has called in or had a friend call in and got someone who gave them information such as the accountholder's name and address, and it ended very badly (we're talking the accountholder calling in later screaming due to now dealing with death threats, vandalism, even physical violence).
Leave a comment:
-
Man, if I had a nickle for every time I'd ask someone for some information to confirm their identity and account and got "You're NOT ALLOWED to ask me that!!" in response, I'd be a rich man.
Sorry sir, as fortune would have it you're not the only John Smith who has an account with us. I don't know what you think I'm going to do with that super-secret classified info aka your home phone number, but I assure you it's just to weed through the 1,000 other people that share your name.
Leave a comment:
-
I hate those people! They say "I'll call you and check on it" and I'd think, no, you probably won't. sigh. If you look up the store phone number in the customer order search, you'll get a large number of current and past employees (usually I'd notice the store phone number before I realized the name was an employee) and the handful of people who refused to give a phone number.Quoth MissVendetta View PostIn the book shop we got customers who wanted to order a book and wanted that we would let them know when their book had arrived, but refused to give their names, addresses or phone numbers. "Why do you want to know that?!!?"
Err...no reason...
Leave a comment:
-
"But why do you need that just to let me purchase X tiny item!?"
or
"I don't think you need to know that."
I don't care where you live, I'm just required to ask for whatever reason the corporate office asks. I'm even more required to ask since you plan to pay with check or credit.
But my percentage of sales with names has gone up. The manager created a name file for our store, so we can use that for when SCs pay up front after which the items must be returned out of hardware, the cash given to us, and the items rung up again in the separate electronics so inventory and the books for both stores are correct.
Now I just use that ID for people in a hurry or the Privacy Act SCs lol.
Leave a comment:
-
Well sir, we could just hire a psychic to telepathically search the area for your psychic trace and implant the command to come to our store and pick up the book. However to recoup the losses of hiring the psychic, we would also have the command implanted to purchase a large selection of our high-priced books that we can't seem to get rid of.Quoth MissVendetta View PostIn the book shop we got customers who wanted to order a book and wanted that we would let them know when their book had arrived, but refused to give their names, addresses or phone numbers. "Why do you want to know that?!!?"
Err...no reason...
Leave a comment:
-
In the book shop we got customers who wanted to order a book and wanted that we would let them know when their book had arrived, but refused to give their names, addresses or phone numbers. "Why do you want to know that?!!?"
Err...no reason...
Leave a comment:

Leave a comment: