Three more reviews of three beers I had at 2 of our craft beer bars.
From the first one yesterday, I tried Southern Tier's Hop Sun and Shiner's Hefeweizen.
The Hop Sun is Southern Tier's summer wheat beer. The nose smelled basically of boring beer. I hoped for more from the taste. My hope would be in vain. It was nothing special, and not really even all that wheaty. In my notes I said the taste was "lame" and on a "Widmer level." I think we all know how I feel about Widmer's "hefeweizen." On the Jester ten point scale, Hop Sun gets a 2. I was, at least, able to pound it down and move on to the next one.
Shiner's Hefeweizen was, at least, cloudy in appearance, and looking like a hefe should look. It had a wheaty but subtle nose, and a nice if average taste. Not bad, but nothing special. 5 out of 10. In a pinch, this will do as a hefe, but there are far better ones out there. At least it's not Hop Sun or Widmer.
At the second bar, I tried yet another of Rogue Brewery's offerings. Yesterday's selection: Chatoe Rogue First Growth OREgasmic Ale, a pale ale. It had a hoppy, distinct, and good nose. The taste was interesting and somewhat hoppy. Not to IPA levels, but definitely at the pale ale plateau. As some of you may know, I've never had a Rogue I didn't love. Well, that streak came to a halt with the OREgasmic. While decent enough, it wasn't great by any stretch, and frankly, I wasn't super thrilled with it. Considering how many of Rogue's offerings I've tried, the fact that it took this long before I tried something I wasn't in love with is pretty damn impressive. OREgasmic is decent enough for what it is, but frankly, I expect better from Rogue. If I had to score the OREgasmic, I would give it a solid 6. As I said, good....but not great.
From the first one yesterday, I tried Southern Tier's Hop Sun and Shiner's Hefeweizen.
The Hop Sun is Southern Tier's summer wheat beer. The nose smelled basically of boring beer. I hoped for more from the taste. My hope would be in vain. It was nothing special, and not really even all that wheaty. In my notes I said the taste was "lame" and on a "Widmer level." I think we all know how I feel about Widmer's "hefeweizen." On the Jester ten point scale, Hop Sun gets a 2. I was, at least, able to pound it down and move on to the next one.
Shiner's Hefeweizen was, at least, cloudy in appearance, and looking like a hefe should look. It had a wheaty but subtle nose, and a nice if average taste. Not bad, but nothing special. 5 out of 10. In a pinch, this will do as a hefe, but there are far better ones out there. At least it's not Hop Sun or Widmer.
At the second bar, I tried yet another of Rogue Brewery's offerings. Yesterday's selection: Chatoe Rogue First Growth OREgasmic Ale, a pale ale. It had a hoppy, distinct, and good nose. The taste was interesting and somewhat hoppy. Not to IPA levels, but definitely at the pale ale plateau. As some of you may know, I've never had a Rogue I didn't love. Well, that streak came to a halt with the OREgasmic. While decent enough, it wasn't great by any stretch, and frankly, I wasn't super thrilled with it. Considering how many of Rogue's offerings I've tried, the fact that it took this long before I tried something I wasn't in love with is pretty damn impressive. OREgasmic is decent enough for what it is, but frankly, I expect better from Rogue. If I had to score the OREgasmic, I would give it a solid 6. As I said, good....but not great.
Comment